|
JLA #61
Mildly Recommended (6/10)
|
DC Comics
"Two-Minute Warning"
Writer: Joe Kelly
Pencils: Doug Mahnke
Inks: Tom Nguyen
Colors: David Baron
Letters: Ken Lopez
Editor: Dan Raspler
"The Power Principle"
Writer: Kurt Busiek
Pencils: Tom Grummett
Inks: Wade Von Grawbadger
Colors: Alex Sinclair
Letters: Comicraft
Editor: Peter Tomasi
Price: $2.25 US/$3.75 CAN |
This stands as a decent first issue, introducing each character and their abilities, giving every member of the team somewhere to shine, keeping the scale big enough for the JLA and delivering some really beautiful artwork. Unfortunately, the characterization of each characters is lacking, and the story really doesn't have much in the way of consequences, almost taking the scale too far over the top. It's time for more of a change in approach for JLA, I think, because
only Grant Morrison could carry off the widescreen style he brought to the book,
and even he never captured it perfectly.
While Kelly has written team books with his work on X-Men, he is at his best with single characters, and that does show to some degree here. While the
structure is sound, giving every character a sequence of their own, the
characters all seem a bit too similar. They are all confident wisecrackers with
infinite power, and the lack of diversity in approach or personality leads them
all to seem a bit bland, even if the aggregate effect is one of cosmic power and
ultimate confidence.
There are some exceptions, though. Despite
similarity of personalities, Kelly does give us some really effective moments
here. Seeing the massive power of a Green Lantern ring contrasted against its
wielder being unable to afford a cup of coffee is a nice commentary on the
mortality behind these cosmic powers, for example. Also, seeing Batman carry on
several conversations in different frames of mind while sparring with Wonder
Woman maintains the uber-Bat characterization that Morrison set as the gold
standard to follow for the book.
Though I sometimes have problems with
Mahnke's work on facial expressions, notably in longer shots, I can't fault most
of the artwork here. He captures the scale of the story with enormous titans
battling each other or Kyle lifting Long Island out of place, and he does some
nifty design work on the nasty little beastie behind the whole mess. The artwork
on this title has always been hit or miss, from the uneven Howard Porter to the
frequently absent Bryan Hitch to the multitude of fill-ins, but Mahnke and
Nguyen are definitely more hit than miss.
The backup feature was what really drew me to this issue, as it's our first glimpse of Kurt Busiek and Tom Grummett's new project The Power Company. Honestly, while reading
it, I was thinking that the dialogue and narration was stilted, but a revelation
about the nature of the story revealed that stilted dialogue as part of the
story, at which point it switched to a more natural form of writing. This is
very much a light piece, with not much in the way of plot and a teaser for the
villain that is utterly generic. However, as an introduction to the characters,
it's top notch, illustrating their powers and basic personalities, and I really
enjoy the look of the team that Grummett and Von Grawbadger have crafted. In any
case, while it's not a stunning debut, it's an interesting teaser, which is
about all you can expect from a short back-up.
Email Randy Lander comments about this review, or discuss it on the Fourth Rail message board. |