by Randy Lander

MAGIC PICKLE #4

Highly Recommended (9/10)

Magic Pickle #3

Oni Press
Writer/Artist: Scott Morse
Editor: James Lucas Jones

Price: $2.95 US/$4.50 CAN

Those of you who dislike puns will hate this issue. The rest of us, of course, will be laughing ourselves silly, as Morse takes the term "food fight" to very literal extremes, and resolves the more important question of Jo Jo's affections for Danny Johnson as well. Though I felt as if Jo Jo's part of the story was rushed off stage a little too quickly, I can't help but get behind the wacky tone of the book. When I first started reviewing this book, I said that you had to love a book that starts out with "and in local news, a rogue group of farm-fresh produce has seized control of the art world." You've also got to love a book where the final battle hinges on the outcome of a food fight in an elementary school.

I did have problems with this issue that I didn't with the rest of the series, namely that I felt like there was a lot more material to explore, and the stopping point seemed a bit artificial. Interactions between Jo Jo and Pickle at the house, as he shows an almost "Tick-like" ability to miss the obvious (such as a throw rug), are pure gold, and I would have loved to have seen more of these two growing into their partnership. In addition, though the Danny Johnson subplot has been important, it's definitely been a side element, and to have that resolution as the ending of the mini-series seemed a bit odd.

Of course, a bit odd doesn't even begin to describe the rest of the book, and I mean that in a good way. The goofy and stupid nature of the various Brotherhood of Evil Produce members makes for some solid laughs, and seeing Jo Jo casually reach up and slam the Romaine Gladiator back into her lunch bag reminds us that this is all in fun. The super-hero elements are parody as much as anything else, because no one is really in any danger here.

Morse really kicks things into overdrive with the puns this issue, once the food fight begins. As a fan of the pun, at least in small doses, I greatly enjoyed the banter between Pickle and Romaine. I also really enjoyed the fight sequence, complete with a nice fork spinning maneuver that apes martial arts films in a hilarious bit of parody.

Though I was a little letdown with the abrupt ending, there is a bright side to that. It seems clear that there are many more stories to tell with Magic Pickle and Jo Jo, and it is my hope after reading this initial series that we will be seeing many more of them.


Email Randy Lander comments about this review, or discuss it on the Fourth Rail message board.

 
Other Reviews by Randy
   
Other Reviews by Don
   
   

all contents © & TM Don MacPherson, Randy Lander, except columns which are © & TM their authors