BATGIRL #23
"Little Talk"
Recommended (7/10)
|
DC Comics
Writer: Kelley Puckett
Pencils: Damion Scott
Inks: Robert Campanella
Colors: Jason Wright & Digital Chameleon
Letters: John Costanza
Editor: Michael Wright
Price: $2.50 US/$4.25 CAN |
This issue is a special one in the run of the series. Not because of the "full cover" gimmick, not because it's a good jumping-on point. It's special because it boasts the best artwork of the series so far, and perhaps the finest effort Damien Scott has put forth in his pencilling career thus far. There's a crispness and kinetic quality to it. The script also brings a clearer view of the title character and the subplots... a bit too clear, actually.
After a close encounter with a bomber, Batgirl opts to "relax" in Oracle's holographic simulation room, sparring with a virtual Lady Shiva, the deadliest martial artist on the planet. Oracle takes the opportunity to discuss Cassandra's state of mind with the Batman, and they have a fundamental disagreement about their young charge's past.
There's something far more focused and intense about the art in this issue. Though the same sleek, energetic tone is to be found, there seems to be a sharper, more defined look as well. Just check out the first panel on the fifth page; there's a mesmerizing, haunting quality to the title character's eyes. The manga influence on Scott's work has never been more apparent, but it's not overpowering. I love the ghostly greens with which Wright bathes the hologram sequences.
Puckett pulls off a nice trick when it comes to characterization in this issue. The focus is not solely on Batgirl. Oracle and Batman both have their time in the psyche spotlight. I was particularly impressed with how Oracle is portrayed as still living in the Dark Knight's shadow, but also as someone who's grown to be more than an assistant or sidekick. She challenges him, and it makes for good reading.
This issue is an excellent jumping-on point for new readers, because the Batman and Oracle, through their conversation, sum up the title character, her past and her feelings perfectly. A little too perfectly, truth be told. Though new readers will benefit, I found the literal script to detract from the title's mystique somewhat. Over the past two years, regular readers have come to learn these things about Cassandra gradually, and hearing the conflict spelled out so matter-of-fact-ly seems... wrong somehow.
Email Don MacPherson comments about this review, or discuss it on the Fourth Rail message board.
|
