I ran into writer Scott Beatty briefly at the Comic-Con International San Diego, and he had two questions for me: (1) why no Ruse reviews lately, and (2) why no Batgirl: Year One reviews? My answer to the first question was easy and easily defended: an issue of Ruse hadn't made its way into my hands in some time (if only I had a better excuse for BY1).
Well, the latest chapter in the life of Simon Archard has turned up here at The Fourth Rail, and in addition to some specutacularly detailed artwork, it offers a couple of other things: confusion, followed by entertainment.
Simon Archard has returned to his sprawling manor after being found innocent of the murder with which he'd been charged recently. Alas, a moment's peace is fleeting. A trio of criminals have infiltrated the enormous home, and they've got murder on their minds. Causing them some problems, though, is the confusing layout of the mansion, Archard's houseguests and their own bumbling. Emma Bishop frantically searches for Simon, while the invaders take care of Archard's other friends.
Butch Guice's artwork boasts a remarkable level of detail. His two-page spreads convey the immensity and majesty of Archard's home perfectly. He brings an amazing sense of realism to bear here, and Perkins's inks adds a clean, classic look to the penciller's normally gritty style. The computer effects add a nice touch to the climax, as another intruder is revealed.
Beatty makes the mistake of failing to provide sufficient exposition to bring new readers -- and readers who've been away from the title for some time -- up to speed. It's never clear who the three criminals are or why they're doing what they're doing. Furthermore, I have no idea who Michelle is, or Lucius or even the mysterious pistol-bearing fellow. The background information provided on the inside front cover deals more with a subplot that plays no part in the action of this issue; it's a shame it didn't dwell on characters others than just Simon and Emma.
As I made my way through the confusing storyline, I was ready to give up on the book. Then, about halfway through, the main protagonist, Simon Archard, shows up, and a measure of clarity, excitement and entertainment accompanies him. His cold, efficient and even quietly sarcastic manner is captivating. Beatty also kicks the humor into high gear around that point in the book as well. I book I was ready to dismiss became one that had me smiling and engaged.
